• Blog posts
    • Spirituality
    • Constructive Criticism: Book reviews
    • Random musings of an eternal optimist
    • Mahabharata
    • Blogging ‘Eureka’ tips & ideas
    • World of Books & I
      • Book writing tips
    • Social Causes
    • Haiku
    • Blog Milestones
  • My novel – Arjun: Without A Doubt
  • Arjun – Anecdotes, free excerpt, quotes, reviews, journey memories
    • Arjun Anecdotes
    • Download Free Excerpt (pdf)
    • Arjun : Journey of my Novel
    • Quotes from Arjun:Without a Doubt
    • About Author
    • Book reviews for Arjun: Without a Doubt
  • My Pencil-sketches

Impractical Dreamer

~ Dr Sweety Shinde: As a butterfly flits; so does the mind waltz in innumerable flights. Mine hovers over books, spirituality ,humor and random gems from everyday life.

Impractical Dreamer

Category Archives: Mythology

Book review: Shakuntala the woman wronged by Utkarsh Patel

08 Monday Aug 2016

Posted by dr sweetyshinde in Classics, Constructive Criticism: Book reviews, Debutante Authors, Mythology

≈ 14 Comments

Tags

book review, dushyant, independent, legitimacy, Mahabharata, mythology, shakuntala, strong women, utkarsh patel, vyas and kalidasa

A confession – I’d totally forgotten that Ved Vyas is the original writer (inspite of being an ardent adorer of his work). It’s Kalidasa’s romanticized version that was ingrained into my mind since childhood.

shakuntala_with_friends_op46

Yes, Shakuntala used to be my most-wanted bedtime story. Of course, it’s not the Vyas version that Mom narrated to me – and finally I know why. Vyas was a hardcore realist. No illusions, no lovey-dovey hackneyed sentiments. No blurred vision. Just cold, brutal realism. A huge hug of gratitude to Utkarsh Patel for re-introducing us to Ved Vyas’s Shakuntala. A woman, in so many ways, a worthy predecessor for Vyas’s Draupadi.

Kalidas’s Dushyant had the convenient excuse of Durvasa’s curse to forget Shakuntala after the secretive Gandharva marriage. Vyas’s Dushyant seduces, uses and discards Shakuntala.

shakuntala-dushyanta-ER06

Twitter review – A tale from abandonment to abandonment, culminating in liberation. An emphatic and empathetic female pov.

Shakuntala is the love child of Kshatriya-turned–sage Vishwamitra and the heavenly nymph Menaka. Rejected by an furious father & forced into abandonment by a reluctant Menaka, Shakuntala is adopted by sage Kanva. Shakuntala nurtures an independent mind, curious queries and clarity of thoughts as she questions men, power,dharma, laws and politics around her.

She gets an opportunity to practice what she preaches, when King Dushyant weds, beds and then dumps her. Shakuntala cuts through the riff-raff to reveal his ugly self to Dushyant. She ensures her son Bharat’s royal heirloom before she walks off into a lonely horizon with her pride, values & dignity intact.

Pros:

  • An opportunity to revel in Ved Vyas’s original genius and his consistent homage to fiercely independent women.
  • Kudos to Utkarsh for writing so tenderly & heartfelt from a woman’s pov, whether it’s about  Ahalya, Menaka, Shakuntala or Madhavi.

His reply: I think all of us have a woman in us and all women have a man within them. Its the theory of anima and animus which works. In my case, the understanding of the women’s psyche is probably more defined and I have never shied away from accepting this factor.

My Q: Did Dushyant have other marriages in the 6 years between his 1st and last meeting with Shakuntala? If so, what would be status of Bharat vis-a-vis other royal heirs and the heirarchy?

His reply: Majority of the versions are silent about Dushyant’s other wives. It could just be a guilt factor which did not allow him to remarry. I have brought his angle about his guilt, when the minister suggests that he get married but Dushyant demurs.

  • Utkarsh also neatly juxtaposes Dushyant’s hunter views ‘ He did not like to hunt if there was no chase.’ It fits in perfectly with Dushyant’s views on feminine conquests.

Cons:

  • First few pages have dialogues of 2 characters crowded into one paragraph. It’s wholly unexpected from a Rupa publication.
  • I found it self-defeating when Shakuntala extracts a pre-nuptial promise of legitimacy for her son. She however extracts none for a daughter, thus making a daughter as vulnerable to subsequent slurs as herself. Given her feminist tirade, it seems out of character. But that probably, is a query targeted at Vyas rather than at Utkarsh.
  • The title should have read ‘A woman to be proud of’ instead of ‘A woman wronged’. The latter gives Shakuntala a victim tag, which she vehemently refused to become.

Verdict: Timely & time tested, well researched (Utkarsh does hold a degree in Comparative Mythology from Mumbai university) and well presented woman’s perspective by a male author. Recommended for admirers of mythology, Ved Vyas and fiery women.

Genre: Mythology/ Fiction

Publication: Rupa

Author contact: www.utkarshspeak.blogspot.in

Price: Rs 295/-

Pages: 269

combo

#Read about Guest #Author Dr. Sweety Shinde

29 Wednesday Jul 2015

Posted by dr sweetyshinde in Arjun - my published novel, Arjun : Journey of my Novel, Arjun Related posts, Download Free Excerpt (pdf), Mahabharata, Mythology, Reblogged posts

≈ 19 Comments

Tags

arjun, arjuna, author interview, Bhagavad Gita, blurb ideas, book spine, books, cover design, fiction novel, Goodreads Giveaway, Guest blogpost, Indian epic, kurukshetra, Mahabharata, mythology, writing tips, youtube trailer

I got an opportunity to grace Chris Graham’s platform for authors. Here it is…

Chris The Story Reading Ape's Blog

VRSOlZ

Perfect quote – It aptly sums up the motive to pen my novel.

Sweety Shinde 01
Why write at all?
You cannot inhale and not exhale.
You cannot eat and
not poop.
You cannot read and
not write. (Did I just equate writing with pooping?) Yin & Yang. Reading is a passive, pleasant passion. Writing is challenging, invigorating, and pathologically addictive!

Profession vs Passion: I’m a Pathologist by profession. I dissect dead bodies and diagnose live diseases under the microscope. But human beings hold deeper mysteries beneath the visible surface. Mind, emotions, and idiosyncrasies – those are beyond the scalpel, but not beyond the pen’s might!

I decided to use my profession 2 ways. One, to fund my passion. Two, to stimulate both halves of my brain – the rational and the creative. Yin & Yang again. 

Flexing the muscles of Time: ‘Work expands to fill the time required to complete it.’ As a…

View original post 880 more words

Book review: Shattered Dreams

13 Friday Feb 2015

Posted by dr sweetyshinde in Mythology

≈ 17 Comments

Tags

bharat, book review, game of life, Rama, Ramayana, shattered dreams, shubh vilas, sita

Premise: Part II of VI Ramayana series.

Story : Post Ram-Sita’s marriage upto Ram’s departure on 14 year Exile.

Tweet version: Mythology buffs know this span includes Keikeyi’s royal tantrum, Manthara’s manipulative move, Dasaratha’s cave-in and Rama’s ‘slip-between-cup & lip’ brush with Ayodhya’s crown.

So how does this 23 word Tweet translate into 386 pages?  Pretty smooth, in the able hands of Shubh Vilas. cover book

                            I liked :

1] Sparks of human emotions within exalted characters- For example Dasaratha (who feels envious & nervous when his courtiers cheer Rama’s coronation – and Dasaratha wonders if they are cheering the end of his reign!), in Rama (after he finds out Kaikeyi’s wish – ‘Here, before Sita, at last Rama dropped his guard. Every leader needs room to express his feelings. Sita was not just that space, she was a deep lake.’)

2] Rama’s angst : ‘Outside were people who expected him to lead. Inside were people who expected him to follow.’ – as he struggles to bridge the gap between being the perfect crown Prince and the perfect son.

3] Sita : Shubh Vilas justifies why he thinks original name of epic was Ramaa-ayana, story of Sita. His Sita is glorious & feisty – using logic, reason, love, pleas and even unexpected insulting taunts Continue reading →

Krishn, the Rorschach test.

18 Monday Aug 2014

Posted by dr sweetyshinde in Mythology, Random Musings, Spirituality, World of Books & I

≈ 13 Comments

Tags

atom bomb, bhagvada Gita, Bhagwad Gita, choice, festivals, gandhiji, interpretation, kansa, Krishn, Krishna, kurukshetra, non-violence, oppenheimer, perspective, war & philosophy

Bhagwad Gita inspired Robert Oppenheimer for Hiroshima-Nagasaki’s ‘Liitle Boy & Fat Man’  atom bombs.

Bhagwad Gita inspired M.K. Gandhi’s Ahimsa (Non-violence movement) as a strategy for India’s freedom struggle.

One source. Polar interpretations. 

Bhagwad Gita is a Rorschach test. So is its orator, Krishn.

On the eve of Janmashthami (Krishn’s birthday), let us try to explore the Krishn Rorschach. 

He plunged through the entire gamut Continue reading →

Book Review : Shikhandi & other tales; Devdutt Pattanaik.

01 Friday Aug 2014

Posted by dr sweetyshinde in Arjun Related posts, Constructive Criticism: Book reviews, Mahabharata, Mythology

≈ 17 Comments

Tags

alternate sex, arjun, arjuna, bheem, ghatotkacha, indra, Krishn, Mahabharata, mythology, shikhandi, shiva, transgender

Oven–fresh offering by mythologist Devdutt (which means God-gift; and  ironically, is a namesake for Arjun’s conch in Mahabharata)

Devdutt takes up the unexplored theme of ‘queerness’ or alternative gender in Mythology. In Part I, he tracks the universal existence of ‘queerness’ across Indian, Persian, Aztec, Viking, Japanese, Mesopotamian and Greek mythology.

Part II is a carefully chosen plethora of ‘queer’ tales. I could discern an interwoven pattern Continue reading →

← Older posts

Enter your email address to follow this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 1,485 other followers

Rage of the Maggots

Psychological Thriller/Short stories

3 lives. 3 moods. 3 novellas. Psycho Thriller/Medical drama

Arjun: Without a Doubt

Indian mythology novel

Silence, too, can be misquoted. Discover Arjun beyond the warrior extraordinaire (Indian Mythology)

Categories

Posts: Toppers & Winners!

Shyam chi Aai: Sane Guruji, Book Review
My novel - Arjun: Without A Doubt
Download Free Excerpt (pdf). Arjun: Without A Doubt
Yuganta (end of an era): Irawati Karve, Book Review
Kartikeya: Arjun’s brother–in-law!
Arjun’s conquests without the Gandiva bow

ArjunTheNovel

ArjunTheNovel

Goodreads

Oven-fresh posts!

  • Stuck
  • Irrationally Passionate by Jason Kothari
  • Atheist or otherwise – by fault or default?

Blog Stats

  • 54,458 hits

Blogroll

  • Sunil Shinde Sketches Watercolors, Architecture, Urban sketching, Travel sketches, Seattle, India, Greece … Sunil Shinde Sketches Watercolors, Architecture, Urban sketching, Travel sketches, Seattle, India, Greece … 10

Add book to your Goodreads shelf

Arjun: Without a Doubt

I belong to IndiBlogger !


IndiBlogger - The Largest Indian Blogger Community

BlogAdda

Visit blogadda.com to discover Indian blogs
Follow Impractical Dreamer on WordPress.com

Hi there Visitor! Live Traffic

Insync with my wavelength

The Blog Farm

The Blog Farm

Click here to kick me higher on BlogAdda

http://www.blogadda.com/rate.php?blgid=50479

Tick, tick, tick

February 2021
M T W T F S S
1234567
891011121314
15161718192021
22232425262728
« Jan    

Need a specific word?

Upcoming Events

No upcoming events

Visitor’s opinions

dr sweetyshinde on Atheist or otherwise – b…
Dr. Swapna Mali on Atheist or otherwise – b…
dr sweetyshinde on Download Free Excerpt (pdf). A…
dr sweetyshinde on Download Free Excerpt (pdf). A…
Mansi on Download Free Excerpt (pdf). A…

Archives

Blog at WordPress.com.

Privacy & Cookies: This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this website, you agree to their use.
To find out more, including how to control cookies, see here: Cookie Policy