• Blog posts
    • Spirituality
    • Constructive Criticism: Book reviews
    • Random musings of an eternal optimist
    • Mahabharata
    • Blogging ‘Eureka’ tips & ideas
    • World of Books & I
      • Book writing tips
    • Social Causes
    • Haiku
    • Blog Milestones
  • My novel – Arjun: Without A Doubt
  • Arjun – Anecdotes, free excerpt, quotes, reviews, journey memories
    • Arjun Anecdotes
    • Download Free Excerpt (pdf)
    • Arjun : Journey of my Novel
    • Quotes from Arjun:Without a Doubt
    • About Author
    • Book reviews for Arjun: Without a Doubt
  • My Pencil-sketches

Impractical Dreamer

~ Dr Sweety Shinde: As a butterfly flits; so does the mind waltz in innumerable flights. Mine hovers over books, spirituality ,humor and random gems from everyday life.

Impractical Dreamer

Category Archives: Mythology

Book Review : Shikhandi & other tales; Devdutt Pattanaik.

01 Friday Aug 2014

Posted by dr sweetyshinde in Arjun Related posts, Constructive Criticism: Book reviews, Mahabharata, Mythology

≈ 17 Comments

Tags

alternate sex, arjun, arjuna, bheem, ghatotkacha, indra, Krishn, Mahabharata, mythology, shikhandi, shiva, transgender

Oven–fresh offering by mythologist Devdutt (which means God-gift; and  ironically, is a namesake for Arjun’s conch in Mahabharata)

Devdutt takes up the unexplored theme of ‘queerness’ or alternative gender in Mythology. In Part I, he tracks the universal existence of ‘queerness’ across Indian, Persian, Aztec, Viking, Japanese, Mesopotamian and Greek mythology.

Part II is a carefully chosen plethora of ‘queer’ tales. I could discern an interwoven pattern Continue reading →

Yuganta (end of an era): Irawati Karve, Book Review

23 Wednesday Apr 2014

Posted by dr sweetyshinde in Arjun Related posts, Constructive Criticism: Book reviews, Mahabharata, Mythology

≈ 18 Comments

Tags

arjun, arjuna, bhishma, book review, draupadi, irawati karve, karn, karna, Krishn, Krishna, Kunti, Mahabharata

She wields the pen like a scimitar and her mind like a microscope.
As she dissects various personas of Mahabharata, she is brutal, incisive and decisive. Passionate (in her arguments) yet dispassionate (towards individuals).

Yuganta_The-end-of-an-epoch1 Her take on Mahabharata is not linear narrative; but deals with individual personas, as she scoffs at the halo around them and simultaneously humanizes and demystifies them.
Many scholars usually steer clear of Krishna Continue reading →

Taali-Ban The Hindus

13 Thursday Feb 2014

Posted by dr sweetyshinde in Constructive Criticism: Book reviews, Mythology, World of Books & I

≈ 7 Comments

Tags

ban, book, book ban, controversy, Hindu, Hinduism, hypocriscy, parody, Penguin India, religion, sarcasm, Wendy Doniger

Penguin: ‘’Get me the Khajuraho orgy capture. Pronto.”

Wendy: Sir, this is not porn. My book covers the grave interpretation and inter-relation between History and Religi…”

Penguin: ‘’Lady, you will be the grave of me. You stick to writing. Leave the sales pitch to me. I need eyeballs for your 800 pages of dry research. Now where is that orgy?”

Wendy: ‘I warn you, this will backfire. In the age of wendysocial media, a misleading cover page that does not match inner contents will never sell.”

Penguin: ”Then match the contents with the cover-page. Unless you have a better idea.”

PA: “Eureka! Ban it.” 

Wendy: “You dolt. We are discussing how to market the book; not how to blanket it…”

Penguin: “PA, you are promoted! Lady, ever heard of the forbidden apple? Adam-Eve would have never bit into it if not for the lure of the guilty pleasure.”

PA: ‘’I know all too well. My kids wont eat that damn apple until I drown it in sugar, custard and cinnamon. I even need to sneak broccoli into pasta.”

Penguin: “Shush! Make it controversial. Let’s publicize this book as an insult to Hindus. We have very thin skins, our tender sentiments bruise easily. Especially when a non-Indian does it. Never mind what we do with our religion ourselves.”

Wendy: ‘’What do you do with it?”

Penguin: “The Bhagwad Gita, for instance. We pass it from one dirty hand to another; extortionist, smuggler, murderer. It stands as mute witness to blatant perjury, exploitation and injustice. Meanwhile, Gandhari holds up the scales and smirks in her dark corner. So, as my PA says, pry open the wounds and let the blood spurt!” untitled

Wendy: ‘’I don’t understand. We came to discuss publicity tactics for my book. This is defamation.”

PA: “There is a difference???”

Penguin: “Her naïveté warms my heart. So then, when there is controversy,50 % will flare into a rage and demand our blood; 50 % will rush to defend our freedom of expression. The remaining…”

Wendy: ‘’Err..you used up all 100%”

PA: “Quiet! He markets books. Don’t teach him how to twist figures and tally percentages.”

Wendy: ‘’Woof, woof.Thump, thump.”

PA: ‘’Meow. Scratch!”

Penguin: ‘’ Now, now, behave like humans. The 50% defenders will purchase it, to protect their skin and to show-off a copy on their book-shelf…”

PA: (sotto voce) “Who knows, some of them may even read it!”

Penguin:’’I heard that. The protesting 50% have to buy it. I mean, if they need to provide proof to the court, they will need to scan, peruse and highlight the controversial passages. Hence, we get the protestors as our customers!”

PA: ‘’Teeny-weeny doubt. How will we sell the book if there is a ban?”

Penguin:’’Child, I rely on Gandhari for that. She will grant us a 6 month golden-period between now and the ban. We smirk all the way to my bank in these 6 months. Besides, there is pdf, wmv, e-pub…”

Wendy:’’I object strongly. I have put years of research into the book. Now I have to survive on snarls, slogans and smut?”

Penguin:’’ Incredible…you can even create poetry! Did you just mention smut? The smuttier, the better. That will expand my customer base; to include all those who will purchase the book; if only to flick through the pages and zero in on the smutty sexual innuendoes.”

Wendy:’’You are demeaning my work, my patience, my art…”

Penguin:’’Did I mention the 3-book contract?”

Wendy: “Gulp. 3 book contract?”

Penguin:’’Your Hinduism has sparked a tangential volcano in my mind. We have 36,000 Gods. Maybe even 330 million. Now, imagine one controversy per God. Let’s begin with Dwarka and its orgies.”

Wendy:’’ (Splutter, gasp, blanch) What blasphemy is this? I am a researcher……not a …”

Penguin:’’Then Re-Search. Discover. Uncover. Rip the lid off. We Indians believe History only when researched and chronicled by foreigners. Now imagine the 16,000 wives pining in Dwarka, their frustration, the cat-fights, the harem politics…”

Wendy:’’ Harem? You are confusing the Mughals with…”

Penguin:’’Whatever. Who cares? Just make it juicy and we will suck it up. “

Wendy:’’You are insane.”

Penguin:’’Why would I be a publisher if I wasn’t insane? Now bring on the Khajuraho book-cover, please. Honestly, I am a God-send to the publishing world. I need to get a patent on this ban-trick before others try the same.”

Wendy:’’ India is a democracy. To ban is the act of Tali-ban.”

PA: “Sir, on that note…de taali!” Continue reading →

Complexity of ideas and Simplicity of words: Rise of Sun Prince, Book Review

24 Tuesday Dec 2013

Posted by dr sweetyshinde in Constructive Criticism: Book reviews, Debutante Authors, Mythology

≈ 3 Comments

Tags

book review, ISKON, Jaico, mythology, Rama, Ramayana, shubh vilas, Sun Prince

…in my view, the above combination makes for rich literature.

The author, Shubha Vilas Prabhu forces your eyes to read laterally and vertically at the same time. Every incident has its parallel interpretation and insight as a footnote.

The narrative ,in a non-linear sequence goes through Rama’s childhood up to his marriage. Delightfully , the latter half focuses on Vishwamitra. His repeated attempts, failures and sheer perseverance to become Brahmarishi is a beacon of hope for every person who loses heart at failure in life.

There are slivers of refreshing details: like Ayodhya following the rainwater harvest system; why Ayodhya means unconquerable; how Saraswati tongue-twisted Kumbhakarna into deep slumber; why Kaam dev is called Ananga( thus implying that Lust is merely a state of mind). Why Rama snapped the Shiva bow instead of merely stringing it; there is a lucid clarification for it too.

There are nuggets of sharp one-liners in the footnote:

Personal favorites include 1. To make mistakes implies lack of foresight; not repeating mistakes is a sign of intelligence 2.The mind is a connoisseur in converting trivial puddles into bottomless oceans. 3. A good leader knows the art of delegation. He himself carries the most demanding role- of being Inspiration 4. Most people want a mentor who will tell them exactly what they want to hear. The process of mentoring the mentor 5. The most vulnerable time to commit mistakes is when victory is close at hand 6. The degree of insult is inversely proportional to the size of the entity causing it.

Such countless gems scattered across the book warrant encores and re-re-rereads. Sun Prince

My only grudge would be making the marriage age of Rama as 12 years. Especially as there is love at first sight and Sita’s feverish feelings for Rama’s broad shoulders. At age 12?

A few questions: If Parshuram, Rama and Krishn were all reincarnations of Vishnu;

1. How did Parshuram coexist with the latter two? Parshuram was a Brahmin who annihilated Kshatriyas, while Rama & Krishn were Kshatriyas.

2. If Rama gave up Sita to uphold his citizens’ doubts over her purity; Krishn married 16,000 women to uphold their doubtful purity. Isn’t that a study in contrasts?

I am confident the author will take up the gauntlet and provide us with lucid clarifications in his coming series. I have attended his sessions on Bhagwad Gita. He is extremely eloquent and articulate.Sun Prince

That aside, Book 1 makes one anticipate Book 2 for more interwoven tales, fresh perspectives, well-researched details and of course, that treasure trove of insightful footnotes.Congratulations!

Here is Book 2 review link!

Newer posts →

Enter your email address to follow this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 1,473 other subscribers

Rage of the Maggots

Psychological Thriller/Short stories

3 lives. 3 moods. 3 novellas. Psycho Thriller/Medical drama

Arjun: Without a Doubt

Indian mythology novel

Silence, too, can be misquoted. Discover Arjun beyond the warrior extraordinaire (Indian Mythology)

Categories

Posts: Toppers & Winners!

Pregnant Nun and ‘Parth’enogenesis in Mahabharata
Abhimanyu’s womb training. Proof of Garbh Sanskaar
In search of the perfect Jeans
Download Free Excerpt (pdf). Arjun: Without A Doubt
book review- the old man on the beach & ...
Krishna: my miracle-Part I

Follow me on Twitter

My Tweets

ArjunTheNovel

ArjunTheNovel

Goodreads

Oven-fresh posts!

  • book review- the old man on the beach & …
  • Yoga, Kundalini, Vipassana, Reiki
  • Code Blue

Blog Stats

  • 64,953 hits

Blogroll

  • Sunil Shinde Sketches Watercolors, Architecture, Urban sketching, Travel sketches, Seattle, India, Greece … Sunil Shinde Sketches Watercolors, Architecture, Urban sketching, Travel sketches, Seattle, India, Greece … 10

Add book to your Goodreads shelf

Arjun: Without a Doubt

I belong to IndiBlogger !


IndiBlogger - The Largest Indian Blogger Community

BlogAdda

Visit blogadda.com to discover Indian blogs
Follow Impractical Dreamer on WordPress.com

Hi there Visitor! Live Traffic

Insync with my wavelength

The Blog Farm

The Blog Farm

Click here to kick me higher on BlogAdda

http://www.blogadda.com/rate.php?blgid=50479

Tick, tick, tick

June 2023
M T W T F S S
 1234
567891011
12131415161718
19202122232425
2627282930  
« May    

Need a specific word?

Upcoming Events

No upcoming events

Visitor’s opinions

dr sweetyshinde on book review- the old man on th…
Ken Powell on book review- the old man on th…
dr sweetyshinde on Code Blue
Rajagopal on Code Blue
On max on Pregnant Nun and ‘Parth…

Archives

Create a free website or blog at WordPress.com.

Privacy & Cookies: This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this website, you agree to their use.
To find out more, including how to control cookies, see here: Cookie Policy
  • Follow Following
    • Impractical Dreamer
    • Join 456 other followers
    • Already have a WordPress.com account? Log in now.
    • Impractical Dreamer
    • Customize
    • Follow Following
    • Sign up
    • Log in
    • Report this content
    • View site in Reader
    • Manage subscriptions
    • Collapse this bar
 

Loading Comments...