‘Devotees create a God out of a mortal – it absolves them of any responsibility to behave like their idol.’
– says Govind Pansare about Shivaji Maharaj, Tukaram and Dnyaneshwar.
In an eerie premonition, he second guesses their mysterious deaths too –viral fever, samadhi & flying chariot respectively used as elaborate cover-ups for their elimination. Did he anticipate his own assassination too?
‘Shivaji Kon Hota?’ (Who was Shivaji?) is a slim (70 page) sharp analysis on Shivaji Maharaj.
Pansare does not deify Shivaji. Instead he takes down Shivaji from a temple sanctum – but places Maharaj on an even higher humanitarian pedestal.
He shoots down myths on Shivaji’s miracles (The famed Bhavani sword wasn’t a gift from a goddess, but crafted in Portugal)– and instead sings paens on Maharaj’s foresight, eye for detail (his soldiers were raised from farmers and allowed to return to farming – this gave them an empathy for civilians, women, children and crops as nothing else could) razor sharp administration, decisive moves, chivalry (every campaign had strict norms of not brutalizing or enslaving ladies of any caste and of not demolishing any worship place) and single minded devotion to Swarajya.
He cheers Maharaj even as he sneers at his pseudo-devotees, the ones who misuse Shivaji’s aura for personal & political motives, the ones who commit every crime using Shivaji’s shield – crimes that would have Maharaj throw them over a precipice.
Shivaji’s vision was Swarajya (freedom), not Hinduism. His earliest army was sculpted from farmers and shepherds, his navy from fishermen and merchants; barbers like Jiva mahal (Afzal Khan assassination) and Shiva (Panhala fort escape) played a protective role while his chief spy Bahirji Naik belonged to Ramoshi caste. Muslim converts like Nimbalkar and Netaji Palkar were embraced back, not ostracized. Yet, while a brahmin Dadoji Kond dev trained young Shivaji, there were also Brahmins who performed Koti Chandi yagna to pray for Shivaji’s defeat by Jaising.
‘’Great men face rigid opposition in their lifetime – some even get assassinated. But if their revolutionary ideas stay alive in people’s minds, then their enemies find a novel technique to kill them once again.
They do a volte face and disguise themselves as bhakts (followers). They distort, mutilate and corrupt the original ideas – and present this corrupted version as THE vision to a gullible public. Nobody knows – or cares to know the difference.”
Pansare draws parallels in current times. For every vatandar sytem that Maharaj tore down, today there are panchayats, MLAs, sugar barons , corporations sucking away public blood. For every rapist that Maharaj had blinded, today’s political parties turn a blind eye to them. For every Madari Mehtar (Agra escape) and Daulat Khan (Naval commander) in Maharaj’s army, today Hindu Muslim riots are instigated using Shivaji’s pretext.
Pansare points out how Shivaji glory has been throttled from pan Bharat to Maharashtra, then further down to Maharashtrian Hindus and then further down to high caste Hindus.
Pansare was dangerously close to an inconvenient truth. Of course they had to kill him. Or … have they?
Maharaj still rules hearts and minds. The book is in its 4th edition and 45th reprint. Hope is still alive.
Somali K Chakrabarti said:
True, it is convenient to idolize heroes and put them on the pedestal of God for then people can bask in their reflected glory without having to behave like them.
LikeLiked by 1 person
dr sweetyshinde said:
Isn’t it? He really nailed it right
LikeLike
Jyoti Arora said:
I haven’t read this book. But I have read about Shivaji a little bit. And what you have written sounds so true.
LikeLike
dr sweetyshinde said:
Its the genuineness of his writing that impressed me, it seems straight from the heart. He didn’t even need to use flowery language or elaborate sequences.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Love, Life and Whatever said:
Hero worshipping in every culture sets a trail which still manifests in today’s society from celebrity craze to Bhakts. When emotions or convinience takes over reasoning somewhere the imbalance in idolising is the key. Very engaging review and its instigating me to read the book but alas I guess I am not capable of reading Marathi.
LikeLike
dr sweetyshinde said:
Good news, the English translation is available on Amazon!
Very valid point about the wide spectrum of hero worship. The problem is when this worship spills beyond personal choice to a public compulsion. And even more when its a distorted version to spread their own perverted views instead of the genuine ideals of the hero
LikeLiked by 1 person
Rakesh Pandey said:
Deification is the ultimate homage humanity can provide to a mortal. The famed pyramids of Gizeh, Khufu and Khafra were designed by the Royal Architect Imhotep in the 24th dynasty. He had achieved the impossible in those times. He was initially praised, then respected and ultimately deified in the 28th dynasty. Unfortunately, the next step after deification is ignominy. Once people deify someone, they forget that the person was a mortal and the achievements were the results of hard work and foresight. They attribute all the achievements to his divine power and simply forget them in a way.
It’s really unfortunate! Shivaji was a pioneer but is reduced to a statue, who’s celebrated every year.
LikeLiked by 1 person
dr sweetyshinde said:
Very succinctly put, I concur on every word. I think the same happened with Sai baba who kept protesting his deification, but to no avail. As for statues, they r another expensive way of wasting public money on private whims.
I’m sure Shivaji Maharaj would have preferred the budget spent on naval fortification rather than on his ocean statue. He in fact set up a navy in anticipation of a sea attack, much b4 Pak terrorists invaded via sea. So Maharaj would have loved his foresight emulated, rather than his birthdays.
LikeLiked by 2 people
Rakesh Pandey said:
Right. That’s the major issue, Sweety. I never thought that way about Sai Baba, but what you said makes a lot of sense! He was deified and a trust took over his humble abode, which became one of the richest temples in India! Irony!
LikeLiked by 1 person
dr sweetyshinde said:
Exacto. Nobody oversees if the original’s ideas and ideologies are followed or sacrificed at the first altar.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Alok Singhal said:
I am very poor in History, but what you have mentioned rings a bell. The book seems to be selling like hot cakes!
LikeLike
dr sweetyshinde said:
I sure hope so. Atleast it should reach the correct hands and then percolate into the right minds.
LikeLiked by 1 person
parwatisingari said:
Sounds interesting Sweety, will try to find it in the library. By the way shall we have an interaction with you april 2nd saturday?
LikeLike
dr sweetyshinde said:
Sure, it has an English translation also on Amazon.
What is the 2nd April interaction about?
LikeLike
........... said:
No wonder we have so many gods. 🙂 . Actually it’s a 3 stage process
Stage 1:
Society is directionless, lacks enthusiasm and energy. Older gods and idols no longer generate kind of enthusiasm they used to when they emerge. society is just continuing with what they have. Their idea for life has passed its expiry date long ago.
Stage 2:
A new voice is heard. It captures the minds of people. Despite all the resistance and numerous adversaries , this person wins over the people. he/she generates so much enthusiasm that people are highly emotional about him/her rather than rational. During the lifetime of that person, many stakeholders emerge who live by his/her popularity. They invest their lives in spreading the name and ideas of that person.
Stage 3
the person concerned dies. But still some stakeholders want to keep up the good work. After sometime they also die and new stakeholders emerge. These are rent seekers. They don’t give anything to society. They do two things
1. Create a cult
They do so that they could do rent seeking indefinitely. Also, they don’t want new voices to emerge and replace old voice. They create a new kind of idolatry. Now we cannot follow the person but we have to pray to him and his godly soul will take care of everything. We don’t need to learn anything from his/her struggles . We don’t need to follow a difficult path. We dont need to question the society like our idol did. because he/she is godly while we are mere mortals. Everyone will taunt if anyone tries to play “GOD”.
2. Create an enemy
In stage 2 of this process, we have seen that new voice emerges despite numerous adversaries. But what after it has won over its enemies ? Neither the person is there to give new ideas and direction to society nor are his/her enemies. The only way out is to create an enemy and do fear mongering among the followers. now the rent seekers are saviour of a cult which was never meant to exist by it’s so called founder. The saviour are the new Adversaries for any new voice .
BACK TO STAGE 1.
LikeLiked by 1 person
dr sweetyshinde said:
Wow, what an analysis. SPot on!
I never realized before that Gods can have their own shelf life and expiry dates. Infact devotees are almost like fanclubs who crest and trough with new upcoming starlets.
As for ideas, it is so easy to kidnap them, mutilate them and give them a new palatable look.
In stage 3, first line… do you think it can be redesigned into ‘The person concerned is killed’?
LikeLiked by 1 person
........... said:
If that person is killed, New stories are made. For example
1. He was killed because of a godly promise or a promise made in previous birth.
2. The person said something like – ” I forgive you “, “hey Ram ” etc. before dying.
3. The person got killed because he was paying for sins done by humanity.
In our favourite book MAHABHARATA, none of the cult figure got killed in normal fashion:
a. Bhisma : didn’t fight
b. Dronacharya: Didn’t fight
c. Karna: Couldn’t fight
d. Krishan: By mistake
And if none of the above, Rebirth.
LikeLike
dr sweetyshinde said:
Do you believe in rebirth?
I do. Simply b’cos there has to be some recycling. Energy to energy. A human cannot vaporize into nothingness, even after incineration.
LikeLiked by 1 person
........... said:
I do.
Life is not just metabolic process. But I believe that someday science would understand how it happens.
Ancient thinkers have given so many theories regarding this, but they are mystical in nature. There can be scientific explanations too. Someday we will find out.
Right now, I believe it slightly, but my stand is ” I dont Know for sure”. I am a seeker.
LikeLiked by 1 person
dr sweetyshinde said:
That’s the best way to approach it. A mind open to possibilities will always absorb better than the 2 extremes – a mind snapped shut in protest or dazed into blind acceptance.
LikeLiked by 2 people
parijatshukla2014 said:
great 🙂
LikeLiked by 2 people
........... said:
Thank you 🙂
LikeLike
SilentShadow said:
No glorious history has been presented in front of us as it was.
Opporrunitists modified it and this modifications are having long and long history. Some context of GEETA was changed (mistranslated) by the personal life
LikeLike
SilentShadow said:
*some context of GEETA was mistranslated by some Orthodox peoples, even Church also hid the fact about Jesus’s personal life and coming to the era of Shivaji maharaj, the history of their own son, Sambhajiraje was also molested by too much extent…
Don’t know why some paradoxical minds do such things..
When they are either opposed or about to be exposed, then they do it…eliminate that person and give him/her the form of God…!
This is going on and on since the ages…!
Congratulations for the factual and clean post. It was really nice.
LikeLiked by 1 person